Back in college, when I started taking writing more seriously, I sometimes wondered when to end a chapter. I sought guidance, and found little to no real help. I wasn't sure exactly how to create that little oomph at the end of a chapter or that satisfying beat of (temporary) closure.
Today, you can find many resources on how, when, or where to end chapters. In truth, though, you don't need a long list of ideas. You don't even need to necessarily rack your brain for a killer cliffhanger or a satisfying conclusion. Nor are chapter breaks a mystery you have to guess at.
The reality is, when you understand plot, structure, and scenes at a foundational level, it will become consistently clear where the best places are for chapter endings. Usually the best place is one of five. Really.
In order to explain those places, though, we need to briefly cover those foundational elements.
Chapter vs. Scene
Unfortunately in the (novel-)writing community, the terms "chapter" and "scene" sometimes get used interchangeably, which is confusing and inaccurate. Many speak of chapters as if they are scenes.
A chapter can be a scene.
But not every chapter is a scene, and not every scene is a chapter.
These are two different things.
A scene is one of the smallest structural units we use in writing. This means it usually has its own little rising action, climax, and falling action--it has a mini story arc.
A chapter is arbitrary. It can technically start or end wherever the writer wants it to (though some places work better than others).
It's common to start and end chapters based on scenes. One scene may be one chapter. This is why people in the community often talk about chapters like they are scenes.
But a chapter can have more than one scene.
And it can have fewer than one scene.
It can have part of a scene.
Or it can technically be made up of only summary and no scene.
The chapter is "artificial."
The scene is less so.
Understanding Scenes (with Plot and Structure)
Since the scene is a structural unit, it will usually have a rising action, climax, and falling action--these things are just "smaller" than that of the overarching story.
This also means a scene usually has a goal, antagonist, conflicts, and consequences (what I consider the primary elements of plot).
As an example, we can look at the scene where Harry Potter arrives at King's Cross to board the Hogwarts Express. The goal is to board the train.
But Harry runs into obstacles (read: antagonists that create conflicts), which make up the rising action. There doesn’t seem to be a Platform 9 ¾. There are only Platforms 9 & 10. He asks a guard for help, but the guard has never heard of Hogwarts, and after some back-and-forth, he gets frustrated and walks away. Harry considers some other options when he overhears the Weasleys, whom he decides to watch, but he keeps missing what's happening with them.
Eventually, he approaches, seeking help, and Mrs. Weasley explains he needs to go through the barrier between 9 and 10. Nervous, Harry runs at the barrier and gets through. This is the climax--the "peak" that resolves the current conflict and turns the scene.
In the falling action, Harry takes in the platform, and finds an empty compartment to ride in.
The "consequence" of all this, is that he will now be on his way to his new school (because he was able to resolve his current conflict (if he hadn't figured out the barrier, he wouldn't be on his way)).
That's the scene.
Frequently, a scene will play out in one location, through a continuous timeframe (like King's Cross during the 10 o'clock hour), but technically, it doesn't always have to. Because of this though, people often define scenes by setting (time and place).
A scene's falling action will often include the character's emotional and logical reactions to what just happened, and then after this, the structure repeats. Rising action. Climax. Falling actions.
Generally speaking--there is always room for "rule breaks" and variations (especially with scenes).
Where to Best Place Chapter Breaks
Deciding where to place a chapter break shouldn't feel like reinventing the wheel. It shouldn't feel like you have to struggle and strain to come up with the chapter's ending.
If you have your plot and structure handled properly in your scenes, then there are five places that are ideal and will work well naturally.
1. At the End of a Scene
As mentioned, many people prefer to align scene endings and chapter endings. Going back to our earlier example, this would be when Harry finds his empty compartment.
This placement usually brings the chapter to a satisfying conclusion, because the current conflict has been resolved.
If you desire, you can work to put in a cliffhanger line here. This is usually easiest done by having the character anticipate what's going to happen next or in the near future. For example, we could end with Harry anticipating what Hogwarts school will be like. We could show he is hopeful about how magical it will be, or, more likely, how fearful/nervous he is that he won't belong there. This then encourages the reader to keep reading. They'll want to know if reality will be what the character anticipates.
With that said, you do not always have to end a chapter on a cliffhanger. While that is often viewed as ideal, sometimes a moment of rest or closure is what the audience wants and needs. This can be particularly true at the end of an act. So, if you want that rest, simply end the chapter with the scene.
2. Right After the Climax
Another great place is immediately after the climax. Because this is just after a high moment where a conflict gets (somewhat) resolved, the audience will be invested and interested in reading what happens next. They'll want to know how the characters react or how their situation changes. They'll want to know about any ramifications or consequences. This propels them to the next chapter. It creates a natural cliffhanger.
In our example, this would be Harry just getting through the barrier, arriving on 9 3/4.
3. Right at the Climax
Another natural cliffhanger that works well, is to put a chapter break right at the scene's climax. This is a more intense ending than the previous spot (but can also "break up" the moment more, so it feels a bit more disjointed--which isn't necessarily a problem, but something to be aware of).
This would mean ending the chapter just as Harry runs or "hits" the barrier.
4. Just Before the Climax
The peak of a structure is usually made up of two mini moments. Something happens externally, and then the character gets to decide what to do in response.
In our example, Mrs. Weasley reveals to Harry that he needs to run at what appears to be a solid barrier ("something external"). Harry gets to decide if he's going to do that (he does).
You can place a chapter break just after the "something external" for another cliffhanger.
So we would end the chapter after Mrs. Weasley's reveal: Harry needs to run at what appears to be a solid wall.
The audience will want to know how the character responds to this and so will read on.
5. After the Inciting Incident of the Next Scene
In story structure, the inciting incident is what kicks off the conflict (simplistically speaking). In our example, Harry discovering there are only platforms 9 & 10, but no 9 3/4 is the inciting incident. It's something unexpected that disrupts his journey. It kicks off the rising action.
Because scene structure is often repeating, you can create a nice chapter ending by completing one scene, smoothly transitioning into the next, and then putting in a break after the inciting incident.
For example, if we had just completed a prior scene, we would transition to King's Cross (likely with some summary), have Harry start looking for the right platform, and end the chapter as he realizes it doesn't seem to exist.
Structurally speaking, these are consistently the five best places for chapter breaks. They either give the ending that oomph (which I was looking for when in college) or that moment of closure. And the last four naturally create cliffhangers, so you shouldn't have to rack your brain to find one.
And while a writer can technically put in a chapter break anywhere, the reality is, it's usually not that effective to place one in the rising action or falling action. It's usually not a good idea to start the next scene and put the break before its inciting incident. These are often awkward places that feel off because of how they disrupt the "climb" or the "drop" of the scene.
Now, has this been done effectively? Sure. There are even some spots in the falling action where you can get away with this more.
Other Considerations for Chapter Breaks
Beyond scene structure, there are some other elements that may influence where to best put a chapter break.
1. A Change in POV
If you change POV in your story, then that change is usually best done at a chapter break. This technically isn't required, but it's effective and so popular these days that if you don't do this, some readers may get confused and some writers may push back on you.
So if you have multiple POV characters, then you should probably start a new chapter when we are in a new character's head.
Rarer (and not recommended), some stories may actually change the written point of view from first to third, or omniscient to second, etc. When this happens, it's often also a good idea to start a new chapter. For example, The Night Circus by Erin Morgenstern features a recurring second-person POV. These moments are separated from the main story by short chapters.
2. A Leap in Time or Place
If there is a significant jump in time or place, then it may be a good time to use a chapter break. This can help emphasize or signal the change to the audience.
(Worth mentioning, though, is that often a POV change or a leap in setting will align with the end of a scene.)
After writing all this, I feel like the next natural question is, how long should a chapter be? The truth is, because chapters are more arbitrary, there isn't a right answer. While rare, some chapters are only a few words and others may be 50 pages or longer. These days, it's pretty common for a chapter to be 10 pages, or . . . 8 - 12 pages. Before that, it was common for them to be 20 pages.
Chapter length can also affect pacing. Short chapters make the story feel faster. Long ones make it feel more leisurely.
Personally, I feel that breaking a chapter at one of the "best five places" is more important and effective than fretting over length.
*I feel I should mention the scene of Harry Potter at King's Cross does not actually have a chapter break in any of these places, as the chapter goes on into the next scene. It's just an example scene I used to demonstrate the principles.
0 comments:
Post a Comment
I love comments :)